Naser Al-Moghamis states his method in the preface, and it is what makes the book usable in an actual conversation.
A religion should not be judged by the opinions of its hostile critics, nor by the behavior of some of its nominal followers — every group has bad people in it, and judging by them is misleading, since they may be violating the religion they claim. A religion should be judged by its teachings, and by the effect those teachings have on people who actually follow them.
So the comparison is made from the sources. The Bible is the basis of Christian teaching and the Qur'an is the main source of Islamic religion and law, and everything asserted here about either faith is supported by a verse from its own scripture. That removes the usual objection — that the other side has been caricatured — before it can be raised.
What Is Compared
The book works through the questions where the two accounts diverge most sharply, setting the relevant passages side by side:
- The authenticity of the Bible and of the Qur'an, examined in turn
- What each says about God — His power, whether He can be seen, whether He rests or sleeps, His justice, His description, and whether He has a family
- What each says about the Prophets — Musa and Harun, Lut, Sulayman, Ya'qub, Dawud and Ayyub عليهم السلام, including the accounts the Bible gives of their conduct
- What each says about Jesus — his genealogy, the crucifixion, his manner toward his mother, and his own words about himself
Its Tone
The author is explicit that the book does not exaggerate or flatter Islam in order to persuade. It presents the real teachings, sourced, and leaves the reader to weigh them. That restraint is what allows a Christian reader to finish it — and it is why the book has been useful to Muslims who found more combative material closed the conversation rather than opening it.
Who It Is For
Muslims doing da'wah among Christian friends, colleagues and neighbors. Christians willing to examine the comparison honestly. Students of comparative religion. New Muslims from a Christian background working through what changed and why.
Related Reading
